top of page

The Great Vinegar Experiment: Adventures in Motherhood

Oct 21
4 min read

Sometimes the road to something wonderful is paved with good intentions, questionable smells, and a few spectacular failures.


When I first started dreaming up Nadura Herb Co., I knew I wanted to create herb-infused vinegars.


After all, I had an abundance of beautiful, fragrant herbs growing in my garden. And what better way to capture those fresh flavors than in a bottle of delicious vinegar?


Simple enough, right?


Well, somewhere along the way, I had another idea.


What if I made the vinegar itself? From scratch!


Oh, the possibilities!


I could create my own unique vinegar bases using different wines, then infuse them with herbs straight from my garden. The entire process, from start to finish, would be my own creation.


I was practically envisioning the beautiful bottles lined up on my shelves.


There was just one tiny detail.


I'd never made vinegar before.


And So, the Experiment Began

And So, the Experiment Began.
And So, the Experiment Began.

Armed with enthusiasm, a little research, and perhaps an unreasonable amount of confidence, I set out to become a vinegar maker.


I gathered my supplies and started experimenting with several different wines, including Merlot, Sauvignon Blanc, sake, and Brut sparkling wine.


I had jars. I had wine. I had a plan.



What could possibly go wrong?


For those unfamiliar with the process, making vinegar involves encouraging certain bacteria to convert alcohol into acetic acid. Under the right conditions, these bacteria can form a gelatinous-looking substance commonly called a vinegar mother.


A vinegar mother!


How charming is that?


I wasn't just making vinegar. I was apparently starting a family.


And like any enthusiastic new mother, I checked on my little creations regularly.

Were they developing? Were they changing? Was something wonderful happening inside those jars?


I watched. I waited. I sniffed.


And waited some more.


Something Smells Suspicious

Now, here's the thing about fermentation.

It isn't always pretty.


And apparently, it isn't always pleasant, either.


As the weeks passed, I began noticing that my little vinegar experiments weren't exactly developing the way I'd hoped.


The aromas were becoming... interesting.


And not interesting in the way a wonderful new recipe makes you lean in for another sniff.


More like the kind of interesting that makes you wrinkle your nose and reconsider your life choices.


After about three weeks, I decided to put the project on hold.


Surely I just needed to do a little more research, make a few adjustments, and try again.

But the jars remained, patiently waiting for their next chapter.


And then came the final inspection.


Every single batch had developed scum on the surface.


And the smell?


Oh, friends.


Let's just say there was absolutely no mistaking these for a lovely, handcrafted culinary vinegar.


Something Smells Suspicious
Something Smells Suspicious

Into the trash they went. Every. Single. One.

Months of anticipation, several bottles of wine, and my grand dreams of becoming a vinegar-making extraordinaire.


Gone.


I didn't even get a decent salad dressing out of the deal.


A Little Reality Check

I think this is something worth talking about.


When you see a beautiful finished product on a website, it's easy to imagine that everything behind the scenes came together effortlessly.


A handful of fresh herbs, a pretty bottle, a lovely label, and voilà!


But that's not how it works.


At least, it certainly hasn't been my experience.


Building Nadura Herb Co. has involved countless hours of experimenting, tasting, adjusting recipes, taking notes, and occasionally wondering what on earth I was thinking.


Some ideas work beautifully on the first try.


Others need a little encouragement.


And some, apparently, need to be escorted directly to the garbage can.


But here's the important part.


A failed experiment isn't necessarily a wasted experiment.


I learned that making vinegar from scratch is a completely different adventure from infusing vinegar with fresh herbs. It requires the right conditions, careful monitoring, and a healthy respect for the fermentation process.


I also learned that enthusiasm, while wonderful, is not a substitute for knowing what you're doing.


Imagine that!


Meanwhile, Back in the Nadura Kitchen...

Fortunately, my adventures in homemade vinegar didn't stop me from creating the herb-infused vinegars I'd originally envisioned.


I simply took a different approach.


Instead of making the vinegar base myself, I began working with quality, commercially produced vinegars and infusing them with fresh herbs and other flavorful ingredients.


And THAT is where the magic started happening!


Garden Basil, Lemon Chive, Italian, Tuscan, Mediterranean, and Thai...


Each blend developed its own personality, and I discovered just how much flavor you can coax from a handful of fresh herbs.


Those are the vinegars you'll find in the Nadura Herb Co. collection.


And I couldn't be happier with how they've turned out.


Sometimes the smartest thing you can do is recognize which part of a project deserves your attention right now.


For me, that meant focusing on creating wonderful herb-infused vinegars rather than trying to master an entirely new fermentation process at the same time.


Have I Given Up on Making Vinegar?

Not a chance!


I've simply declared a temporary cease-fire.


Winter is coming, and with the garden winding down, I'll have a little more time to revisit the science, figure out what went wrong, and give homemade vinegar another try.


This time, perhaps with a bit more knowledge and a bit less blind optimism.

Although I make no promises about the optimism.


That's pretty much a permanent condition around here.


And who knows?


Maybe one day I'll proudly announce that I've successfully made my very own vinegar from scratch.


Or maybe I'll have another entertaining story about something that smelled terrible and ended up in the trash.


Either way, you'll hear about it.


Because that's what The Herb Journal is all about.


The beautiful harvests. The delicious discoveries. The experiments that succeed beyond expectations.


And the ones that most definitely do not.


So, did I successfully make my own vinegar?


Absolutely not. Did I learn a few things along the way? You bet. Will I try again? Of course!


Apparently, I haven't learned my lesson.


To be continued... 🌿


A little note from my kitchen: Making vinegar from scratch is a fermentation process that requires appropriate methods and safety precautions. My unsuccessful batches were discarded, not tasted or used. Nadura Herb Co.'s herb-infused vinegars are a separate project made using commercially produced vinegar bases.

Comments


bottom of page